The Racquet

Share this post
Sinner and Karatsev Dominate
theracquet.substack.com

Sinner and Karatsev Dominate

Sinner and Schwartzman's serve/return mismatch, Karatsev's brutal consistency

Matthew Willis
Oct 24, 2021
4
4
Share this post
Sinner and Karatsev Dominate
theracquet.substack.com

Sinner d Schwarztman: 6-2, 6-2

A complete and utter serve/return mismatch. While Schwartzman is one of the best returners on tour, Sinner’s recent improvements in 1st serve potency, coupled with Schwartzman’s own lack of a first serve weapon, made this extremely one sided.

After the first set, 67% of Sinner’s 1sts serves had gone unreturned compared to just 5%(!) of Schwartzman’s. After two whole sets it got a little better for Schwartzman, but not by much:

Unreturned 1st serves overall:

  • Sinner: 59%

  • Schwartzman: 9%

Avg 1st serve return position:

  • Sinner: 1.1m behind baseline

  • Schwartzman: 1.7m behind baseline

This serve potency differential manifested in all sorts of ways, but most importantly and simply it meant that Sinner earned a lot of free points and Schwartzman practically none, and that Sinner got to keep his aggressive court position up on the baseline for most of the match when points did develop past the serve, whereas Schwartzman was forced to make his home deep in the court near the tournament logo:

(Still) Sinner’s home today up on the baseline. Schwartzman’s home today on the Antwerp sign.
(GIF) This happened again and again. Schwartzman (far end) would hit a serve, Sinner would easily redirect a return central and deep onto the baseline to take control of the point. Sinner would get to stay up on the baseline and Schwartzman would get pushed further and further back. So far back in this instance that Sinner could exploit the angle with this great forehand. Sinner’s greater weight of shot in what were often cross court backhand exchanges meant that it was usually he who could change direction or look to press first rather than Schwartzman, as you can see here with Sinner easing the backhand up the line. Schwartzman had nearly zero serving advantage today.
(GIF) One of Schwartzman’s (far end) favourite serves is this slider 1st serve out wide on the Deuce side, and it had worked well against his previous opponents this week (Brooksby, Nakashima, Murray), but Sinner just eat it up all match long. Sinner did exactly what he should be doing on return like this, aiming deep and central, jamming his opponent up (similar to what Raducanu did for most of the US Open), patiently but aggressively keeping control of the rally and then attacking the right ball when it comes. Schwartzman usually doesn’t mind getting into these backhand exchanges vs most opponents considering how solid that shot is, but Sinner’s greater weight of shot and ease at changing direction from cross court to down the line meant this dynamic almost always went in Sinner’s favour today. Sinner, with his Nalbandian-esque wrist control on that backhand, can be hard to read with that shot.

Unfortunately for Schwartzman, even when you take the serve performance differential out of the equation, Sinner was still superior from the baseline in neutral, or even initially disadvantaged, positions:

(GIF) Sinner (far end) hits a soft 2nd serve here and Schwartzman gets to play a relatively rare aggressive return into Sinner’s backhand corner. But because Sinner is so complete from the baseline (ie he has both a brilliant forehand and backhand), he still doesn’t give up rally control or any positional advantage. Sinner gets great depth on the backhand and then gets to work out-rallying Schwartzman until the Argentine is pushed back behind the Antwerp logo once again. And one of the bad things about being 5ft 7 a la Schwartzman, is that the trajectory of your ball gets more and more unkind the deeper he moves. Schwartzman generally hits his backhand pretty flat, and from this far back in the court, from his 5ft 7 vantage point, physics is never in his favour (hence the backhand miss half way up the net).

Rally winners:

  • Sinner: 11

  • Schwartzman: 1

Sinner out-served Schwartzman, out-returned Schwartzman (although those two things heavily overlap), and out-rallied Schwartzman on the back of both serving and non-serving positions. This resulted in extremely one sided point length stats, across each category:

I’ve written quite a bit recently about Sinner’s serving improvements this year as he moved away from the pinpoint stance he tried for a few years, and back to his platform stance that he grew up with:

The caveat here is that Sinner’s serve is always going to be more effective on indoor hard courts than some of the slower and outdoor surfaces out there (I’ll keep track of this into next year to see how much of an improvement he’s made overall). But the good signs for his serve effectiveness continued with today’s final, albeit in conditions that may well be flattering. I’ll do some more digging on this but it looks to me like Sinner’s reversion to his original platform stance has allowed the following things on his 1st serve (my guess is that the more fluid motion of his natural platform stance, as opposed to sweeping that back leg forwards mid-motion in pinpoint, is helping these things along):

  • A more accurate and consistent toss.

  • More aggressive placement.

Sinner’s 1st serve placement today was exceptional, landing bombs close to the lines point after point. If I had to guess what Sinner and coach Piatti are working on, and have been working on, the most over the last few months, it’s this.

Stark difference in 1st serve placement between the two players. Sinner (right) going all out for the lines and Schwartzman (left) playing it much safer.

Today’s final was abnormally good, even for Sinner’s recent form, with the Italian hitting his highest ace rate of his tour level career so far at 18%.

An excellent performance from the young Italian, who is in a league of his own progress-wise compared to the rest of his age range right now:

Twitter avatar for @enricomariarivaenrico maria riva @enricomariariva
Most ATP titles for players born 2000 and after Sinner 5 (+1*) Korda 1 Seyboth Wild 1 Cerúndolo J. 1 Alcaraz 1 *Next Gen title
Image

October 24th 2021

10 Retweets40 Likes

Karatsev d Čilić: 6-2, 6-4

I’m not going to go into quite as much detail for this match because the reasons for the result were simpler, but I do want to give a boat load of credit to Karatsev. There has been a fair amount of recent skepticism around the Russian as the season has progressed.

Twitter avatar for @fogmountEd Salmon @fogmount
It mystifies me that the prevailing narrative about Karatsev seems to be “he’s an elite player in a slump” rather than “he’s a fundamentally error-prone player who had a hot streak early this year”.

September 23rd 2021

5 Retweets120 Likes

Karatsev, after the incredible breakthrough in Australia to start the year, lost a few early rounds against tough opponents and all of a sudden he was faced with various ‘flash in the pan’ narratives. But Karatsev’s last few weeks on tour show signs of mmm-blocking out the haters.

While Karatsev’s brand of tennis looks simple, it’s really testament to how technically sound both his groundstrokes are (especially suited to these quick, indoor hard courts), coupled with impeccable footwork, that he manages to pull off such an illusion. Because Karatsev’s level this week, and style of tennis, are not even slightly easy to pull off.

There are two things I want to highlight in this matchup today:

Firstly Cilic (far end) hits a brilliant body serve right onto the line (a consistent strategy today), but Karatsev deals with it extremely well with a backhand return which in turn rushes Cilic’s own backhand (missing the court by about three metres). This point is a nice microcosm of Karatsev’s superior return performance today — Karatsev won more than double the return points of Cilic, 37% to Cilic’s 18%. Also of note here is the reproducibility of their respective backhands. Karatsev has a flat but very solid backhand technique. Cilic’s backhand on the other hand is a contender for one of the more inconsistent strokes that has existed at the top of the men’s game. It’ll usually either be incredible or very error-prone with little in-between.

Cilic’s backhand featured heavily in most of the break points he faced and lost today:

I really liked this play from Karatsev (far end), which he pulled off numerous times today, where instead of going for too much when pushed wide by the Cilic forehand, Karatsev just hits it central, hard and deep back to Cilic’s baseline, never flirting with the sidelines. Cilic can really struggle when rushed on central backhands like this.
Just about any time that Karatsev (this end) and Cilic started exchanging backhands cross court it was not good news for Cilic. Karatsev’s ability to take the ball early while finding consistent depth and pace of shot is seriously impressive when he’s on. Cilic again forced into another backhand miss by over a metre rather than inches.

One of the most impressive examples of Karatsev finding more consistent depth and pace of shot than his opponent, even when under pressure, came when Karatsev faced his only break point of the match while serving for the title:

Cilic (far end) plays the first half of this point pretty much perfectly. Great return, good and deep backhands. But Karatsev soaks it up brilliantly, maintains either depth or pace of shot superbly, and coaxes the error out of the Cilic backhand once again.

A wonderful week for Karatsev. The Russian putting in work to justify his early season hype.

Karatsev, as ever, thrilled by the win…

— MW

Twitter @MattRacquet

See you on Thursday.

Top: Laurie Dieffembacq via Getty, Bottom: Oleg Nikishin/Getty

// Looking for more?

Most recent:

The Racquet
Medvedev loses a match?
Yesterday in Indian Wells Daniil Medvedev lost a match on a hard court. As this doesn’t happen very often these days I thought I’d take a look at why. Medvedev lost to Grigor Dimitrov, despite being up 6-4 4-1 at one point. While Medvedev certainly started to spray unusual errors and looked understandably jaded after his incredible run of recent form, Di…
Read more
8 months ago · 8 likes · 4 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Domestic Abuse In Sport and Tennis
The ATP has announced that their “‘safeguarding report’ is complete and that they will now get to work on a safeguarding strategy relating to all matters of abuse, including domestic violence.” The ATP has also launched an “internal investigation into…
Read more
8 months ago · 6 likes · 7 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Murray's Serving Problem
Andy Murray lost to Casper Ruud yesterday in San Diego. While there’s certainly no shame in that loss, Ruud is No.10 in the world and having his career-best season after all, Murray has high standards, understandably, and probably thinks he should be more competitive in these matches…
Read more
8 months ago · 9 likes · 2 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
The First Four Shots Meme
During the Djokovic Zverev match, in the men’s semi finals of the US Open, there was a 53 shot rally on set point. Zverev won it, saving the first set point in that game. Djokovic then won a 16 shot rally on the very next point, also a break/set point, to take a two sets to one lead. Ma…
Read more
9 months ago · 7 likes · 2 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Medvedev Crosses The Moat
Women’s final: Raducanu return analysis Anyone watching the men’s final would have been able to work out what was happening for the most part, so, for once, this match really doesn’t need too much explaining. Djokovic, physically and mentally exhausted after a tough season and under the pressure of trying to complete the calendar year Grand Slam for the…
Read more
9 months ago · 7 likes · 2 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Raducanu Returns
Leylah Fernandez 1st serve points won by round: 65% vs Konjuh in 1st Round 80% vs Kanepi in 2nd Round 78% vs Osaka in 3rd Round 66% vs Kerber in 4th Round 70% vs Svitolina in quarterfinals 68% vs Sabalenka in semifinals 56% vs Raducanu in the final There are lots of impressive things about Raducanu. She’s extremely balanced on both forehand and backhand wings, …
Read more
9 months ago · 8 likes · 5 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Sliderman
Novak Djokovic is going for the extremely elusive ‘Calendar Year Grand Slam’ this fortnight in New York, i.e winning all four Slams in a row in the same year. I, and others, have written a lot about Djokovic recently, which is unsurprising considering he’s been the best player in the world for large parts of the last decade. And while one of Novak’s big…
Read more
9 months ago · 9 likes · 3 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Rublev's Serve Problem
Neither the men’s or the women’s Cincinnati finals were eventful at all, both completely routine. But one of the matches did feature something I want to go a bit deeper on. Barty d Teichmann: 6-3, 6-1 Zverev d Rublev: 6-2, 6-3 After some crazy ATP semi-finals, in which Medvedev…
Read more
10 months ago · 4 likes · 7 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
A New Playstyle Meta Approaches
After watching Opelka upset Tsitsipas followed by Medvedev defeating Isner in Toronto, I tweeted this…
Read more
10 months ago · 5 likes · 6 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Game, Set, Shit
This will undoubtably be one of the dumber issues of the Racquet I write, but here we go. Yesterday, during his win over Aslan Karatsev in Toronto, Karen Khachanov got in hot water over some particular bits of language. The Russian was given a point penalty for an audible obscenity, down break point, and resultantly lost his serve…
Read more
10 months ago · 4 likes · 3 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Sinner's Serve
Jannik Sinner has put a stop to his mid-season slump in form to reach the Washington final this week. Tonight he plays Mackenzie McDonald for the trophy. Something interesting happened with Sinner’s serve after his round one loss to Jack Draper on the grass at Queens a month or so ago. Sinner went back to the serving motion he used throughout his junior …
Read more
10 months ago · 4 likes · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Wimbledon Final Analysis
Note: I make small edits to these posts if I find mistakes, or if I have anything to add. You can see the most recent version by tapping the title (opens web version) at the top of this issue. Djokovic d Berrettini: 6-7(4), 6-4, 6-4, 6-3 First off I’m just going to quickly go over how much more of a step up this match was for Berrettini, in relation to hi…
Read more
a year ago · 7 likes · 20 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Medvedev Loves(?)The Clay
Danil Medvedev hates the clay, then he loves the clay, then he hates the clay, and now he uh… loves it again. The Russian has been playing some very good tennis in week one of Roland Garros. So good in fact that some may be left wondering whether his…
Read more
a year ago · 10 likes · 4 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Naomi Osaka Boycotts The Press
Naomi Osaka yesterday: “I am writing this to say that I am not going to do any press during Roland Garros. I’ve often felt that people have no regard for athletes' mental health and this rings true whenever I see a press conference or partake in one. We're often sat there and asked questions that we've been asked multiple times before or asked questions …
Read more
a year ago · 10 likes · 8 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
The Federer Redux
Roger Federer played in Geneva on Tuesday for just his third match in the last 15 months. He lost. His opponent was Pablo Andújar, a solid clay courter in decent form on the back of a busy slate of clay events so far this year. Federer was a break up in set three, having played mostly impressive tennis for the latter two sets, but was foiled by some exc…
Read more
a year ago · 12 likes · 2 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Let's Stop Screwing The Umpires On Clay
I’ve wanted to write something on this topic for a while, but two things happened today in Rome that gave me a good excuse. Number 1. Tsitsipas, locked in a very tight 1st set tiebreak against Berrettini, hit this shot (video here…
Read more
a year ago · 9 likes · 10 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
The Modernisation Of Tennis
Tennis, In Need Of A Saviour? Last week Patrick Mouratoglou, the occasionally controversial coach of Serena Williams, made some rather bold claims about the state of tennis while promoting his new ‘Ultimate Tennis Showdown’ tournament: Mouratoglou: “Ten years ago the average age of the tennis fan was 51 years old. Today it’s 61. In ten years it’s going to…
Read more
2 years ago · 18 likes · 3 comments · Matthew Willis
4
Share this post
Sinner and Karatsev Dominate
theracquet.substack.com
4 Comments

Create your profile

0 subscriptions will be displayed on your profile (edit)

Skip for now

Only paid subscribers can comment on this post

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in

Check your email

For your security, we need to re-authenticate you.

Click the link we sent to , or click here to sign in.

Mark Newman
Oct 24, 2021Liked by Matthew Willis

No one else is putting out analysis with this consistency or quality. Bravo

Expand full comment
ReplyCollapse
Susie Reid
Oct 24, 2021Liked by Matthew Willis

Great write up! May I say that Sinner is turning into a formidable indoor player. His brand of tennis is totally suited to it. Hoping he does some damage at the AO given he has developed physically and hopefully gained stamina. His game is ideal for those hard courts. And I hope he makes Turin for the same reasons.

Yes, am thrilled for Aslan, wonderful riposte to the doubters and testimony to his belief in his game.

Expand full comment
ReplyCollapse
1 reply by Matthew Willis
2 more comments…
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2022 Matthew Willis
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Publish on Substack Get the app
Substack is the home for great writing