The Racquet

Share this post
The Disappearance of Peng Shuai and Tennis' China Dilemma
theracquet.substack.com

The Disappearance of Peng Shuai and Tennis' China Dilemma

Sports vs China, different lenses and ideologies, what can tennis do?

Matthew Willis
Nov 14, 2021
8
8
Share this post
The Disappearance of Peng Shuai and Tennis' China Dilemma
theracquet.substack.com

Peng Shuai, a former Wimbledon and French Open doubles champion, has reportedly not been seen since accusing a former Chinese Communist Party official of sexual abuse.

Update from Steve Simon, WTA CEO, via Christopher Clarey: “We’ve received confirmation from several sources, including the Chinese Tennis Association, that she is safe and not under any physical threat,” But Simon also noted that no one associated with the WTA Tour, including officials and active players, had been able to reach her directly to confirm her status:

Source

Background

The original accusation, posted from Peng’s official Weibo account on the 2nd November, read as an open letter to 75-year-old Zhang Gaoli who served as China’s senior Vice Premier (2013-2018), and was also a member of the Politburo Standing Committee (2012-2017). This is the first of these #MeToo, or at least #MeToo adjacent, accusations to be publicly aimed at a senior Chinese Communist Party (CCP) Official. Although to be clear, while this is being widely reported in the West as #MeToo, Peng didn’t mention the #MeToo movement in her accusation.

Peng referenced a previous affair between her and Zhang (who is married) before the official was promoted to the Standing Committee in 2012, but goes on to describe more recent events, over seven years later, once Zhang had retired.

Peng’s short lived Weibo post.

“After I had finished playing, you and your wife Kang Jie took me to your home. You took me to your room, and like what happened in Tianjin over ten years ago, you wanted to have sex with me. I was very scared that afternoon, I had not expected things to go this way. I had buried it all inside me, and since you were not planning on taking responsibility at all, why did you come and look for me again, take me to your house, and force me into sex? I have no proof, and it would be impossible for me to keep any evidence. You denied everything… That afternoon I originally did not consent and cried the whole time. ”

“…From beginning to end, you have always asked me to keep my relationship with you secret, let alone telling my mother that we were in a relationship… I felt like a walking corpse. I was pretending so much every day that I didn’t know who the real me was anymore..”

“I know that for someone of your status, Vice Premier Zhang Gaoli, you’ve said that you’re not afraid. But even it’s like striking a stone with an egg, and courting self-destruction like a moth to the flame, I will tell the truth about you.”

Censored

Peng’s post was deleted within thirty minutes of being posted and the CCP’s censorship machine clicked into overdrive.

Peng's Weibo account has been blocked from searches, while all comment sections under previous posts have been shut down or filtered. Search results and comment sections for Zhang Gaoli also received similar treatment. A Weibo discussion page about tennis was also closed for comments and it was even reported that the Mandarin Chinese word for tennis (网球 - wăngqiú) was censored.

A regular occurrence when censorship like this happens in China is that internet users will find more obscure or unrelated platforms and communities, that are less obvious targets of the initial waves of censorship, to discuss the topic. For example the page of a Korean romance TV show ‘Prime Minister and I’ was censored on Douban (China’s equivalent of IMDB), after users gathered to discuss the Peng and Zhang situation in the movie’s review section.

#MeToo and dissent in China

Unlike the Peng instance, there have been plenty of recent examples of high profile figures being accused of sexual abuse or assault in China while the Chinese Communist Party allows, or even amplifies, the news. The rape allegations against Canadian-Chinese singer Kris Wu for example were allowed to blow up on Chinese social media and remained a consistent news item for days.

The Wu story, alongside sudden crackdowns by way of almost total erasure from the Chinese internet, of extremely prominent celebrities such as actresses Zhao Wei and Zheng Shuang after various (non-#MeToo) scandals, stand out as the Chinese Communist Party leveraging an opportunity to further their agenda. In this instance the recently intensifying agenda of wiping out the influence of ‘misbehaving celebrities’ that the Cyberspace Administration of China (CAC) identified as having a ‘chaotic’ effect on society. These are all small cogs in Xi Jinping's larger scale machinations against political dissent, social activism, ideological liberalism and private businesses, which have manifested in all sorts of ways over the past 24 months. The most high profile of which was when Alibaba’s Jack Ma, one of China’s most successful, visible and powerful entrepreneurs, seemed to fall off the face of the earth after giving a controversial speech that criticised the Chinese state’s approach to its financial systems and regulation. This unfolded just before Ma’s Ant Group (which runs Alipay, one of Chinese largest digital payment platforms) was set to go public at the end of 2020. Ma was widely seen to have been firmly reigned in by the CCP in the aftermath of the speech, his Ant Group IPO was scuppered by Chinese regulators wiping $70b off the value of the company, and this set off a chain reaction of events in which Xi Jinping and the CCP sought to reestablish the all-powerful nature of the state over private enterprise and celebrity. The last two years have seen a massive recorrecting of course to a more pure vision of a culturally insular and controlled China.

Peng Shuai and tennis’ dilemma in China

The Peng Shuai story falls much closer to the Jack Ma example than it does the Kris Wu example purely because of what it reveals about the Chinese Communist Party’s goals. Wu, by way of the rape allegations against him, could readily be used by the CCP as propaganda as to why Chinese citizens should stop viewing celebrities as having all-important, cult-like status. The CCP views the modern obsession with celebrity as a corrupting, western distraction from its own goals, and celebrities misbehaving (both trivially and severely) presented an opportunity to stamp out the trend. The Peng Shuai and Jack Ma examples on the other hand both involve criticism of the state itself, or representatives of the state. This would never be tolerated based on Xi Jinping’s and the CCP’s recent rhetoric. While democratic nations in the West like to hold themselves up as countries where dissent, disagreement and the free flow of information are necessary rights in the machine that is individual freedom and autonomy, China largely views such dissent as far too dangerous to its various, overarching causes.

When looking at how the West and China clash on issues like this it’s helpful to at least try and view the events through their two opposing and entirely incompatible ideologies. Much of the West values individual agency and democracy as tools for human existence and progress. China, while also aiming for progress and the flourishing of its people, has comparatively little faith in its own citizens to self-regulate their behaviour in order to achieve that progress. Freedom and autonomy are replaced with an all-important political mantra of doing what is ‘for the good of the state’, and therefore by the CCP’s own circular logic, also its people. China has banned video games for children, is cracking down on what it calls the ‘sissification’ of society (in Mandarin the “niang pao”), generally considers citizen-led social activism as anti-progress, and even views other religions and ethnicities that reside in China as culturally incompatible with their grand vision (hence their abhorrent treatment of the Uighurs). Contrastingly in many Western nations, a government mandated ban on video games would come across as alien-like heavy-handedness for the general public, while sexual orientation and identity has experienced massive progressivism over the past decade. Any attempt at cultural and religious ‘re-education’ of minorities living within most Western nations would be seen a human rights atrocity akin to Nazism. Movements like #Metoo and BLM for example are only possible, and seen by many as vital stepping stones of progress, in societies with the freer flows of information present in many western nations. The equivalent movements however, unless they serve the goals of the CCP, are largely seen as weakness by the Chinese state, sickly symptoms of rampant individualism and people-power that are fundamentally irreconcilable with the Chinese Communist Party’s long term ambitions for China’s future role as the most powerful country on earth. Numerous Western nations view this Chinese approach as authoritarian overreach. China views it as necessary babysitting of what they see as the dark, distracting sides of humanity in its quest for the most productive, pure and successful society possible.

This dichotomy presents interestingly in the case of Peng Shuai. You have China strongly censoring the story, which squashes its domestic spread but at the same time massively amplifies its international spread in the form of the Streisand effect. Peng’s story has now been firmly picked up by international media with tennis players and other figures within the sport also calling for action.

The question now is what can tennis do?

Tennis has been riding the wave of the two-time major winner Li Na effect for some years now. The WTA inked a ten year contract to hold the WTA Finals in Shenzhen starting in 2018 in a deal worth approx $1 billion, the sport’s largest. And while the last two editions have not been able to be held in China due to coronavirus concerns, the current plan is to return to Shenzhen in 2022. The Men’s ATP tour also acknowledges significant financial interests in China with both its Beijing ATP 500 and Shanghai Masters 1000 events known to be particularly lucrative for the tour (with potential expansion plans in place for both). Overall there are dozens of first and second tier tennis events in China, an increasingly important market in the minds of tennis executives.

When contemplating whether to respond to the Peng Shuai situation there are plenty of recent warnings in the form of other sports when thinking about possible ramifications. The NBA, most acutely of all, know the reality of trying to juggle commercial partnerships in such a strategic market with the wildly different ideologies between the United States (the NBA’s domestic focus) and China.

Twitter avatar for @EnesKanterEnes Kanter @EnesKanter
Taiwan will never surrender to the EVIL Chinese Communist Party. Taiwan is a DEMOCRATIC and FREE country. I #StandWithTaiwan The future of Taiwan must be determined by the Taiwanese people. Taiwan is NOT a part of China and NEVER will be! #IslandOfResilience #FreedomShoes
Image
Image
Image
Image

November 10th 2021

4,037 Retweets17,085 Likes

Boston Celtics NBA star Enes Kanter has consistently criticised China’s stance on Taiwan as well as their treatment of Uyghur’s, Tibetan’s, and Hong Kongers. Kanter even directly referenced Xi Jinping as a ‘heartless dictator’.

For the NBA and the Celtics, Kanter's activism has had obvious and swift consequences. Tencent suspended all streams and broadcasts of Celtic’s games and on Weibo a search for "Kanter" provides no results. All Celtics games, both current, past and highlights, are no longer accessible in China.

NBA Commissioner Adam Silver's support has come only in private to Kanter, who doesn’t exactly feel well supported by the higher ups in his sport:

…if they were really supporting me, they would've put something out there.”

Kanter’s activism, and sport vs China repercussions, are not new. Kanter’s actions come a year after the NBA as a whole was banned, for an entire year, from being streamed in China after the general manager of the Houston Rockets, Daryl Morey, tweeted support for the Hong Kong protesters in 2019. This led several of the NBA’s partners in China to end their broadcasting and sponsorship deals.

Tennis can look around at the NBA et al to understand what may happen should the WTA speak out. Will WTA players who tweet their disapproval of the treatment of Peng Shuai be blocked from having their matches streamed in China? Will they be allowed to play in Shenzhen next year should they qualify? In 2015, the WTA struck a ten year partnership with iQIY, China’s biggest online streaming platform, to show its matches for free. Should the WTA, or any of tennis’ governing bodies speak up, they would be risking the stability of those sorts of sorts of media deals, not to mention the billion dollar Shenzhen contract.

So the question remains, do the WTA and tennis’ other governing bodies have the backbone, or more practically the financial freedom, to risk the loss of these sources of revenue? And the larger, longer-term question for tennis as a whole is whether this sport can swallow its morals to keep the Chinese gravy train of revenue running, or whether a more introspective conversation needs to take place about trying to run many of its largest tournaments in a nation which views ethics through an increasingly divergent lens compared to the nations in which these tennis organisations call home (largely the United States and The United Kingdom). While the NBA have sufficiently deep pockets and ample growth of the sport to ably eat costs like temporary Chinese partnership hitches and media blackouts, tennis, and specifically the WTA, doesn’t have the same level of financial security. It would therefore be quite surprising to see a strong response from the WTA (update: the WTA have now responded, more forcefully than expected), or any organisation within tennis, unless it was already seeking a way to remove itself from an over-reliance on the Chinese market. The replacement city (Guadalajara) for Shenzhen this year for the WTA finals has been a success at least in terms of atmosphere, but it will require an enormous step change of action from the WTA to plot a more permanent change of course.

Above all, let’s hope Peng Shuai is ok, wherever she is.

— MW

Twitter @MattRacquet

Normal match analysis back next week.

Top: Visual China Group via Getty Images

The Racquet goes out twice a week, a (free) piece every Thursday and a (paid) analysis piece every Sunday/Monday. You can subscribe here:

Give a gift subscription

// Looking for more?

Most recent:

The Racquet
The Future Of Tennis - Part 2
NB: This essay focuses on the digital and technological future of tennis more so than things like in-person tournament growth, format changes and participation. More on those soon. Part one is here, it helps but you don’t need to have read it for part two to make sense…
Read more
8 months ago · 8 likes · 3 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Big Serving Counterpunchers... Uh Again
Quick note from Matt: I’m having surgery on Wednesday this coming week (3rd Nov) so there will probably be no issues (unless I can find someone interesting to write a guest post). This unfortunately means there will be no Paris Masters analysis. I’ll update at the end of next week but will be back for the NextGen and ATP Finals…
Read more
8 months ago · 5 likes · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Sinner and Karatsev Dominate
Sinner d Schwarztman: 6-2, 6-2 A complete and utter serve/return mismatch. While Schwartzman is one of the best returners on tour, Sinner’s recent improvements in 1st serve potency, coupled with Schwartzman’s own lack of a first serve weapon, made this extremely one sided…
Read more
9 months ago · 4 likes · 4 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Medvedev loses a match?
Yesterday in Indian Wells Daniil Medvedev lost a match on a hard court. As this doesn’t happen very often these days I thought I’d take a look at why. Medvedev lost to Grigor Dimitrov, despite being up 6-4 4-1 at one point. While Medvedev certainly started to spray unusual errors and looked understandably jaded after his incredible run of recent form, Di…
Read more
9 months ago · 8 likes · 4 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Domestic Abuse In Sport and Tennis
The ATP has announced that their “‘safeguarding report’ is complete and that they will now get to work on a safeguarding strategy relating to all matters of abuse, including domestic violence.” The ATP has also launched an “internal investigation into…
Read more
9 months ago · 6 likes · 7 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Murray's Serving Problem
Andy Murray lost to Casper Ruud yesterday in San Diego. While there’s certainly no shame in that loss, Ruud is No.10 in the world and having his career-best season after all, Murray has high standards, understandably, and probably thinks he should be more competitive in these matches…
Read more
9 months ago · 9 likes · 2 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
The First Four Shots Meme
During the Djokovic Zverev match, in the men’s semi finals of the US Open, there was a 53 shot rally on set point. Zverev won it, saving the first set point in that game. Djokovic then won a 16 shot rally on the very next point, also a break/set point, to take a two sets to one lead. Ma…
Read more
10 months ago · 7 likes · 2 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Medvedev Crosses The Moat
Women’s final: Raducanu return analysis Anyone watching the men’s final would have been able to work out what was happening for the most part, so, for once, this match really doesn’t need too much explaining. Djokovic, physically and mentally exhausted after a tough season and under the pressure of trying to complete the calendar year Grand Slam for the…
Read more
10 months ago · 7 likes · 2 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Raducanu Returns
Leylah Fernandez 1st serve points won by round: 65% vs Konjuh in 1st Round 80% vs Kanepi in 2nd Round 78% vs Osaka in 3rd Round 66% vs Kerber in 4th Round 70% vs Svitolina in quarterfinals 68% vs Sabalenka in semifinals 56% vs Raducanu in the final There are lots of impressive things about Raducanu. She’s extremely balanced on both forehand and backhand wings, …
Read more
10 months ago · 8 likes · 5 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Sliderman
Novak Djokovic is going for the extremely elusive ‘Calendar Year Grand Slam’ this fortnight in New York, i.e winning all four Slams in a row in the same year. I, and others, have written a lot about Djokovic recently, which is unsurprising considering he’s been the best player in the world for large parts of the last decade. And while one of Novak’s big…
Read more
10 months ago · 9 likes · 3 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Rublev's Serve Problem
Neither the men’s or the women’s Cincinnati finals were eventful at all, both completely routine. But one of the matches did feature something I want to go a bit deeper on. Barty d Teichmann: 6-3, 6-1 Zverev d Rublev: 6-2, 6-3 After some crazy ATP semi-finals, in which Medvedev…
Read more
a year ago · 4 likes · 7 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
A New Playstyle Meta Approaches
After watching Opelka upset Tsitsipas followed by Medvedev defeating Isner in Toronto, I tweeted this…
Read more
a year ago · 5 likes · 6 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Game, Set, Shit
This will undoubtably be one of the dumber issues of the Racquet I write, but here we go. Yesterday, during his win over Aslan Karatsev in Toronto, Karen Khachanov got in hot water over some particular bits of language. The Russian was given a point penalty for an audible obscenity, down break point, and resultantly lost his serve…
Read more
a year ago · 4 likes · 3 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Sinner's Serve
Jannik Sinner has put a stop to his mid-season slump in form to reach the Washington final this week. Tonight he plays Mackenzie McDonald for the trophy. Something interesting happened with Sinner’s serve after his round one loss to Jack Draper on the grass at Queens a month or so ago. Sinner went back to the serving motion he used throughout his junior …
Read more
a year ago · 4 likes · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Wimbledon Final Analysis
Note: I make small edits to these posts if I find mistakes, or if I have anything to add. You can see the most recent version by tapping the title (opens web version) at the top of this issue. Djokovic d Berrettini: 6-7(4), 6-4, 6-4, 6-3 First off I’m just going to quickly go over how much more of a step up this match was for Berrettini, in relation to hi…
Read more
a year ago · 7 likes · 20 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Medvedev Loves(?)The Clay
Danil Medvedev hates the clay, then he loves the clay, then he hates the clay, and now he uh… loves it again. The Russian has been playing some very good tennis in week one of Roland Garros. So good in fact that some may be left wondering whether his…
Read more
a year ago · 10 likes · 4 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Naomi Osaka Boycotts The Press
Naomi Osaka yesterday: “I am writing this to say that I am not going to do any press during Roland Garros. I’ve often felt that people have no regard for athletes' mental health and this rings true whenever I see a press conference or partake in one. We're often sat there and asked questions that we've been asked multiple times before or asked questions …
Read more
a year ago · 10 likes · 8 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
The Federer Redux
Roger Federer played in Geneva on Tuesday for just his third match in the last 15 months. He lost. His opponent was Pablo Andújar, a solid clay courter in decent form on the back of a busy slate of clay events so far this year. Federer was a break up in set three, having played mostly impressive tennis for the latter two sets, but was foiled by some exc…
Read more
a year ago · 12 likes · 2 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
Let's Stop Screwing The Umpires On Clay
I’ve wanted to write something on this topic for a while, but two things happened today in Rome that gave me a good excuse. Number 1. Tsitsipas, locked in a very tight 1st set tiebreak against Berrettini, hit this shot (video here…
Read more
a year ago · 9 likes · 10 comments · Matthew Willis
The Racquet
The Modernisation Of Tennis
Tennis, In Need Of A Saviour? Last week Patrick Mouratoglou, the occasionally controversial coach of Serena Williams, made some rather bold claims about the state of tennis while promoting his new ‘Ultimate Tennis Showdown’ tournament: Mouratoglou: “Ten years ago the average age of the tennis fan was 51 years old. Today it’s 61. In ten years it’s going to…
Read more
2 years ago · 18 likes · 3 comments · Matthew Willis
8
Share this post
The Disappearance of Peng Shuai and Tennis' China Dilemma
theracquet.substack.com
8 Comments

Create your profile

0 subscriptions will be displayed on your profile (edit)

Skip for now

Only paid subscribers can comment on this post

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in

Check your email

For your security, we need to re-authenticate you.

Click the link we sent to , or click here to sign in.

Mark
Nov 15, 2021

How are the Chinese tournaments lucrative without a full house? I seem to recall low attendances most of the time

Expand full comment
ReplyGift a subscriptionCollapse
1 reply by Matthew Willis
Susie Reid
Nov 14, 2021

I actually thought it was very carefully worded. Not direct questioning of where she is, no criticism of CCP directly.

Expand full comment
ReplyCollapse
1 reply by Matthew Willis
6 more comments…
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2022 Matthew Willis
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Publish on Substack Get the app
Substack is the home for great writing